Skip to main content

Dead of Winter - Review

Rennie Airth's John Madden series returns with DEAD OF WINTER. The series has taken a leisurely rout toward publication, three books in ten years. The peerless RIVER OF DARKNESS appeared in 1999 with THE BLOOD-DIMMED TIDE showing up in 2004. In the chronology of these books we have jumped from just after WWI to the waning years of WWII. In those years we have seen John Madden move from a seasoned Police Detective to, of all things, a farmer in this latest work.

I don't want to belabor this point, but I really can not think of a finer piece of historical Crime Fiction than RIVER OF DARKNESS. Character, setting, and plotting are exceptional in this book. THE BLOOD-DIMMED TIDE delivered a completely opposite experience. The book was a baffling affair that failed as equally as RIVER OF DARKNESS succeeded. This disappointment aside my admiration is undiminished for John Madden's first adventure. The dichotomy of the first two books made it hard not immediately think about which end of the spectrum DEAD OF WINTER falls into. Is it cheating to say this book falls in the middle?

The murder of an immigrant Polish girl sets in motion the events of DEAD OF WINTER. What unravels from it are killings and assassinations that stretch back decades and traversing the European continent. DEAD OF WINTER is a handsome affair that paints England in the clutches of the WWII conflagration. The book is a return to form in the sense that Mr. Airth is able to paint across the broad canvas of WWII that renders the whole terrible affair with polished detail. Mr. Airth has particular skill at combining the twin cataclysms of war and the more intimate murder of a young girl. It is Mr. Airth's execution of the 'war' across the city and countryside that are enthralling to read.

So where does DEAD OF WINTER go wrong? The story, sort of. A criticism of current Crime Fiction is that expansive back stories blunt the effectiveness of novels as large swaths of the plot and characters are lost to large expository explanations of unseen events. Of course, if done well back story detail fills in gaps and can be become addictive story and character 'crack'. At times this level of detail certainly assists DEAD OF WINTER to become and atmospheric crime riddle. More often, THE DEAD OF WINTER and Mr. Airth just info dump huge pieces of story detail. Within the context of the book it fits because the story requires that the reader learn this new piece information, but the information is not organically delivered. The hand of the author is too present in these moments where a character appears and opens his mouth delivering the exact bit of information we require. Frustratingly, this happens most often in the presentation of the Killer's own story. In much the same manner of his previous novels the killer's story is only revealed through others. The killer is an unknowable specter in Mr.Airth's books. It is a brave choice by the writer particularly as crime fiction today virtually requires that we become fellow travelers with the killer on their warped journey. With RIVER OF DARKNESS, Mr Airth has proven that this technique can work, but in DEAD OF WINTER we left with an inert villain. We are told he is a dangerous man, but I never really felt it.

Still, DEAD OF WINTER is an elegantly mounted book that is richly detailed and rewarding. While I have some issue with how this detail was imparted, I still think DEAD OF WINTER is deserving of your time.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Fogotten Post: A Remembrance

[Editor's Note: Started this missive, never came back to it. Still relevant, I suppose.] I am reading MURDER IN OLD BOMBAY by Nev Marsh. This was... technically still is... on my to buy pile. In the before time... the overwhelming to be read pile time... I would have bought this and thrown it on the shelf to read in the near or more likely distant future. I hope I like it enough to buy the second in the series. Buying a book is fun, buying a book that is good is better. [Editor's Note: Abandoned this book, unfinished.] BLACKTOP WASTELAND - S.A. COSBY So glad I didn't buy this last summer. Good decision to put off buying and reading what would have certainly been one of the best books of the year. New goal for the remaining 2021 calendar. Don't be dumb. Buy Mr. Cosby's follow up and read day one! [Editor's Note: I did buy a signed copy of RAZORBLADE  TEARS, meanwhile B.W. won every award, except the Edgar where it wasn't even nominated!? Also Signed firsts of...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Very Best of Mr. Michael Connelly - Part 2

My August 31 post of The Hungry Detective ranked all the non-Bosch books. This list returns to take on the larger task of Mr. Heironimous Bosch. 9 Dragons made its appearance right before the Indy B'Con, and try as I might... ok I didn't try that hard... I didn't have time to read it for inclusion in these rankings. As a quick aside I don't want to undersell any of the books at the bottom of the list. Mr. Connelly doesn't know how to write a bad book, but in my case there have been occasions where I have not connected with his work. 13. THE NARROWS - 2004 It is because I love THE POET so much that this book is at the end of the list. When Mr. Connelly is at his best his works has the precision of a watchmaker. THE NARROWS just felt forced and not worthy of the intricacy of THE POET. 12. BLACK ICE - 1993 Second book. Third read. I thought the story was pretty flat. It has been well over a decade since I read this book, but the story of Mexican drug runner...
1 comment
Read more

Small Mercies - The Return of Dennis Lehane

 A time honored tradition at The Hungry Detective HQ is to perform the twice annual, and largely ceremonial, 'Dennis Lehane New book 20XX" Google search. Nothing comes up on his long abandoned Website, except notification of the script work for his television and film projects.  Grousing aside, 2022 was a big year for Mr. Lehane. BLACK BIRD, a show he created, played on Apple+ to solid acclaim. The show's star, Paul Walter Hauser, won a Golden Globe. But despite that I have yet to watch it. Not for any other reason than I am a movie person more than a TV person. The TV I do watch is watched in an arcane order that is difficult to decipher and even more baffling to explain. Short story, I need to watch ANDOR [Editor's Note: Slow going on ANDOR despite everyone telling me it is amazing.] And then BLACK BIRD, or maybe SLOW HORSES. I'll get there...  Anyway at the dead end of 2022, I did the search. Found out he wrote a book. SMALL MERCIES . I was excited to hear it. I...
Post a Comment
Read more